Anyone who is friends with me on facebook may have seen that I reposted this article called Rude vs. Mean vs. Bullying that my Student Teaching Coop Teacher posted. I found this article important to repost because I think it is important to be able to distinguish between the three. In this age of Anti-bullying we live in, it seems to me that in an effort to deal with bullying and draw attention to it in order to make it not an overlooked crime, has gotten to the point where any negative behaviour from one child directed toward another child is considered bullying. Because parents and teachers don't want to let it get out of hand, they quash everything and anything that might be even remotely considered bullying. Bugging your best friend about his new haircut might now be quantified as bullying, even though it was meant to be in jest. Schools touting a Zero Tolerance Policy on Bullying may be forced to harsh punishments over such actions if anyone were to report it, whether it be an over concerned parent, a teacher that misinterpreted, or a child that is just trying to do the right thing. Young children especially may have trouble distinguishing between someone being a bully and someone just being rude. The question is then, where do you draw the line, and how do you distinguish mean vs. bullying when talking to a concerned parent? When physical harm comes to a student? Girls are generally more underhanded than that, Female bullies often try to psychologically damage their victims rather than cause physical harm. And waiting until there is some physical damage seems to be too late for me. So where's the line? I don't know, but I think there is value in letting some issues between kids be dealt with by the kids (mom and dad can't always be jumping in to save the day!), but in actual cases of bullying, I think the parents have a lot more control over the situation than the bullied kids do. So being able to differentiate between rude, mean, and bullying actions is important. I feel that rude and mean actions lend themselves to teachable moments, but bullying is something to be stepped in for. If you can't seem to classify, it's probably best to err on the side of caution and help your kids out, of course. But if a kid at school just has no manners, my kids will have to deal with people like that the rest of their lives, best they learn to deal with it now!
The most moving and important conversation of my day happened after I had gotten home from work, showered and threw on my PJs and I decided to have a bowl of cereal before bed. Normally, I would just grab a glass of water and go directly to bed, but I'm glad I changed up the routine last night. Roland went out almost directly after I got home, this isn't unusual, so I didn't think anything of it, but when he got back 1/2 an hour later, and I was sitting on the computer reading news articles, he sat down next to me and said "I think I watched a documentary I shouldn't have watched", he then proceeded to tell me about the documentary Bully, that was released in 2011...
For anyone that is not familiar, this movie follows the lives of a a boy in middle school that is bullied every day, a girl who was bullied to the point of making some really bad choices, a transgender student that is not accepted in her community, and the families of kids that have committed suicide after being incessantly bullied.
I have only ever seen Roland cry once the whole time I have known him, and it was in a situation where he was hammered out of his mind and did something that he really regretted and hurt a friend emotionally without really thinking about what he was doing. Roland was on the verge of tears while talking about the things that happened to the boy in middle school, I think kids are a really big soft spot for Roland. Some of the things the middle schooler, Alex, says are just so heartbreaking that it's tough to even imagine things like this happening to kids anywhere. After having kids threaten to stab him and try to choke him out on the bus, he has a conversation with a school official and says that they are his friends and they were just joking around (there is footage from the bus, and they're not his friends or joking around). The official respond that they are not his friends if they are doing such things to him, to which he responds "If you say these people aren't my friends, then what friends do I have?" Roland was heartbroken to hear a kid say such a thing, and know that he had no one.
Roland wanted me to tell him that things like that don't happen here, and that it's a United States problem, but I really don't think it is. The cases in Bully are the extreme cases, I will give him that, I don't think that things get THAT bad, THAT often, but they happen, and with regularity. But as far as location, I think there is a potential for that to happen anywhere. With the right (or wrong) formula or situations of apathetic teachers, vulnerable students, and inactive parents, etc. it can literally happen in any school setting anywhere. In the case of this movie, most of the bullying took place in affluent communities, entitled kids with no boundaries picking on the weak. I pointed out that in Saskatoon there is a rising per capita rate of gangs in the city, kids are being recruited younger and younger. What is to say that kids aren't being bullied into gangs in schools here? I'm not saying there is, I don't have that kind of intel, but there is definitely a likely potential for it.
Bullying is not just an issue for the victim, it really is a community problem, and in order to limit and stop cases of bullying before they happen, everyone needs to be on board. Parents of both the bully and the bullied, teachers, administrators, bus drivers, chaperones, coaches, ANYONE! Everyone can help out, even if it means not turning a blind eye, being aware, and being accountable. This is really a close issue to my heart and was one of the reasons I went into education.
If you haven't seen the movie, I'd recommend it. As Roland said, it's heartbreaking to the point he wasn't sure if he should have watched it, but I've never believed in the "ignorance is bliss" thing, ignorance is just blind, and I would rather be able to see.



